I’d like to write a richly reflective essay tonight, one that aptly summarizes the human condition as we find it this New Year’s Eve. But I’m not starting out much better than the old British monarchs who usually began their January 1 addresses by saying “another year has passed”.
Over the past year I read about scientific research that finds a deeply embedded instinct within humans toward tribal love and loyalty, and at the same time toward aggressive behavior against those outside the tribe. We just can’t seem to see and trust each other as one big tribe; somehow, either through genetics or via deeply seeded cultural / subconscious presumptions, it just seems right for us to show great love within a small circle of affiliates, but deep hatred and distrust for other those in other circles. That just seems to be our default programming.
But then again, humans are inherently innovative and able to change. We’re not locked into our default programs. If and when we see benefit, we make changes. There are times and places when we came away from the tribal warfare scenario. But when things go wrong, we so easily slide back into it. The whole Iraq war seems like a pretty good case of this, but if you want purer examples you can look to Africa or the Middle East, or just visit an American inner city where rival gangs fight for turf with automatic weapons.
I’m gonna do some talkin ’bout my own generation here. I’m part of the great white Baby Boom, part of the 60’s “peace” crowd (if not by much). I remember the free-floating hope that was in the air back when I was in high school. War and conflict were seen by us as terribly undesirable things. Patriotism and other forms of tribal identification were totally out of fashion. Collectivism was in, and money and greed were out (or so we thought). Love was in the air, at least in theory. We didn’t want to become soldiers of the Cold War and slaves to mortgage bankers like our parents were. We were going to go from happening to happening (like Woodstock), based on trust and openness and sharing and lack of avarice.
Obviously it was a vision made possible because of the wealth afforded to us by those we didn’t want to be like (i.e., our affluent suburban parents). Once we had to take on the responsibilities of finding reliable sources of income and of raising children in an uncertain world, it was amazing how quickly we lost our idealism and started reverting to the old tried and true paradigms, including large doses of aggressive competitiveness, tribal affiliation, and defense if not outright aggression against those without our tribe. Oh, sure, we tried to be a little more open-minded than past generations, but tough times brought on by oil shortages and recessions turned many former “peace children” into Ronald Reagan supporters by the mid-80s.
Today’s popular music is conspicuous (to me) by its lack of idealism. The charts seem heavily dominated by violent rap and sex themes. Rock music, no longer the king of pop as it was in my youth, has retreated lyrically into sarcasm and depression. A song about love and brotherhood wouldn’t have a chance (well, OK, there are occasional exceptions, although some of them are by Michael Jackson – and thus are not good counter-examples these days).
Just for laughs, I’m going to review a few lines from a song from the late 60’s called “Ray of Hope”, as written and recorded by the Rascals (once know as the Young Rascals, who had some pop hits in the mid-60s). Lets try this one:
This world can be a place that’s filled with harmony
First there’s a lot of things we’ve got to rearrange
Put an end to hate and lies
So peace can come and truth shall reign.
Ah yes, shades of Crosby, Stills and Nash, who once sang “we can change the world, rearrange the world”. You don’t hear that one much anymore. Let’s try another line:
There’s people who win without making fists
Oh yea, right, those are the ones who have expensive lawyers.
Next, how about some quaint phrasing?
It’s a gas just knowing what is yet to come
An ironic twist on Nazi genocide (or American industrial pollution, or air quality in Chinese cities)? No, people really took that seriously once.
As long as there is a ray of hope
Lord, I don’t mind going out and doing my work
Am I saying that there is no ray of hope left for 2004 and beyond? Well, no. I still go out and do my work, and that indeed reflects a deeply seeded if dimly felt belief that there is still hope for the human race. Unfortunately, we have taken after the chimps, our primal ancestors, by forming tribes of loyalty that constantly kill and pillage each other. But we can think and learn much faster than chimps can. Maybe one day we’ll finally learn that small tribes and big wars are not in fact the best ways to provide for our children. (One of the biggest stumbling blocks is that so much of our hallowed spiritual literature is steeped in those presumptions; somehow, people in mass will have to find the guts to turn away from the Bible and the Koran and the other great books when they speak of conquest against the heathen “outsiders”). Maybe someday that old academic chestnut, i.e. “it doesn’t have to be this way”, will finally get thru to us. Maybe “someday at Christmas”. OK, that’s a line from a pop tune from not too many years ago. OK, sometimes songs of peace still do make the airwaves. OK, so maybe there is yet a ray of hope then.
Happy New Year.