Philosophy ... Society ...
At present, I’m trying to cut my way through the very dense jungle of prose within a book called “Godel, Escher and Bach”, as written by mathematician Douglas Hofstadter. This book was published in 1979, and gave Hofstadter a taste of fame within the philosophical ranks. The book came out just a few years after Robert Pirsig‘s “The Art of Zen and Motorcycle Maintenance”. Both books were written by off-beat geniuses who offered up concoctions of math, science, philosophy and eastern spirituality to seekers of higher truths. Pirsig made the bigger splash with Zen and Motorcycle Maintenance, which became a best seller in the early 80s. However, Hofstadter has had much more staying power over the past quarter century. Pirsig managed to get another book out in 1991 called “Lila”, which was mostly a dud. However, Hofstadter published a number of well-received works on a variety of techno-philosophical issues over that time.
Hofstadter now has a book out called “I Am A Strange Loop”, which has gained a fair amount of attention. “Strange Loop” presents his solution to the mind-body problem, the ultimate question of what our consciousness is. I’m looking forward to reading it, but I’ve heard that you really should be familiar with Godel, Escher and Bach before taking it on. So I’m trying to get ready, although the 700 some-odd pages of GEB turn out not to make for an interesting and pleasant Sunday afternoon. The author (then a young professor) seemed to think that everyone is in love with number theory and is willing to spend days and days going thru his lessons on how to write a theorem regarding the pattern among positive integers between a prime number and the cube of their successors (next highest number), taking their difference and adding it to the square of . . . . Sometimes you want to throw the book at the wall and say “who gives a ____ “.
But there are some spots where Hofstadter calms down and writes for real people, sharing various insights from his brilliant mind regarding the nature of reality. One insight that I found very interesting regarded ants and bees and neurons. These things all have to do with the fashionable topic of complexity and emergence, which was still quite unknown to the public when GEB first came out. Ants somehow act in unison to make an ant colony thrive; bees somehow make a bee hive work; and neurons somehow make our brains light up. This is despite the fact that in all cases, there is no central controller for the individual ants, bees and neurons. Each one has no idea what the grand plan is. They just do their little jobs. Yet somehow it all comes together to support a great collective effort.
Hofstadter ponders just where the “information” lies that directs the workings of an ant colony, or a bee hive, or the human brain. It does NOT reside in the individual ant, bee, or neuron. NONE of these things can actually talk; but if they could, and if you could ask them what the grand plan is for connecting the caves of an ant colony, or the secret of honey production in the bee hive, or how the human mind composes songs and lyrics, each of them would shrug and say “I have no idea”. The grand plan resides on a higher level, outside of any putative consciousness of the participants.
That made me think back to my recent ponderings regarding warfare. War is one of those things that humans just don’t seem able to control. Wars just happen. Our diplomats try to stop them, but not very successfully in most instances. It kind-of seems like something from a bee hive or an ant colony. The “grand plan”, the “information” behind warfare, seems to reside at a higher level than human awareness, even higher than human collective awareness like national governments or the United Nations (which is pretty much a joke, anyway).
So just what could that “information level” behind warfare be? I don’t like to get spacey and go off on New Age tangents. But I can’t help but wonder if there might be something to the “Gaia hypothesis” regarding a planetary “consciousness” of sorts. Is war Gaia’s way of keeping the human race, with its dreams and grand plans for conquest and control, in check? (Talk about a “STRANGE LOOP”.) Are we just too aggressive and exploitative for the good of the planetary system as a whole, and so the planetary system pushes us into controlling ourselves by a war or ethnic cleansing now and then?
I read somewhere that about 200 million people died as a result of war and genocide during the 20th Century. My almanac says that world population went from around 1.7 billion in 1900 to around 6.1 billion in 2000. Using some rough averaging, I’d guess that around 8 billion people lived during the 20th century (figuring average lifespan just short of 50 years). So, about 2.5% of everyone, or around 5 out of every 200 people, had their lives cut short (usually in young adulthood) because of war.
I’m glad that Gaia let me off the hook. But as the 21st Century progresses, with global warming and nuclear weapons proliferation and worsening wealth and knowledge inequity (with the poor getting poorer, a small handful getting tremendously rich), and as the population level nears 10 billion around 2070 . . . . I can’t help but wonder what Gaia has up her sleeve. Sorry to be such a pessimist, but it may not be pretty. Wonder if Mr. Hofstadter has any ideas on how to cut that Strange Loop short?