The ramblings of an Eternal Student of Life
. . . still studying and learning how to live

Latest Rambling Thoughts:
 
Sunday, January 18, 2009
Medicine ...

As noted in my last two or three entries, I haven’t been writing much lately due to an illness in the family. My mother was in the hospital since Dec. 9 following a respiratory arrest. The medical people weren’t very optimistic about her chances at first, but God and my mother conspired to beat the odds. So she went home yesterday, 39 days after her “lung attack” (it was similar to a heart attack in many ways; in fact, her heart had stopped during the incident).

Thirty-nine days . . . . which is just shy of 40 days, recalling Jesus’s fast in the desert, Jonah’s timeline for the destruction of Ninevah, and Ezikiel’s sufferings for the sins of Judah. Yes, this incident was almost “Biblical in scope”.

The doctors never did give us a good explanation of what happened to my mother. In the end, we had to settle for the fact that the airway passages in her lungs got severely inflamed for awhile and nearly choked her. They couldn’t pin it on an infection, an environmental exposure like smoking or asbestos, or some other medical condition. I myself still think it was an autoimmune reaction. My mother never had a major immune disease (like lupus, MS, Crohn’s Disease, Guillain-Barre Syndrome, Type 1 Diabetes, etc.). However, she has had rheumatoidal arthritis for a while now; not surprising for someone in their mid-eighties. So she has had some autoimmune activity in her body.

Another little factoid from her hospital stay: on her fourth day in the intensive care unit, my mother’s blood hemoglobin levels were found to be critically low, so the doctors ordered a blood transfusion. Following medical protocol, they performed a Coombs test to search for any antibodies in her blood that might interfere with the new blood. And they found them! They asked my brother and me whether she had any previous transfusions; we and her doctor had no such recollection. The hospital where she had a cancer operation eight years ago also had no record of any transfusions. So — why all the killer antibodies in her blood? Maybe they were the same antibodies that had attacked her lungs (and her kidneys, which were also in trouble for a while there)? The doctors brushed my suggestion off, of course.

Nonetheless, there is a lot of interest today in autoimmune disease in the medical research field. Some people feel that what we presently know about autoimmune disease is just the tip of an iceberg. I.e., the medical establishment knows a lot about the most apparent autoimmune conditions (again, like lupus and MS and now arthritis), and has come up with some treatments. However, medicine is not even close to coming up with a cure; the immune system is an extremely complex thing, second only to the brain. In effect it has a “mind of its own”, as it monitors, responds and learns from changing body conditions and internal threats that come from germs and other bad stuff (including when our own cells go awry, i.e. cancer). We don’t understand it, and thus can’t do much to put it right when it makes its own mistakes.

Over the past 30 years, the government and private funders have put millions, maybe billions, into finding the cause for cancer and then finding a cure. It’s starting to seem to me that this is like a child trying to dance or ice skate before it knows how to walk. There’s something we need to get a grip on before we take on cancer, and I’m now thinking that a thorough understanding of the immune system is a big part of it. Immune disease isn’t very “sexy” right now, because it seems so limited; only a relatively small percentage of people will develop one of the known forms of serious autoimmune disease. But again, that turns out to be just the tip of the iceberg. We’re now starting to see just how tied-in the immune system is to all sorts of disease, ranging from cancer itself, to pandemic infections (i.e., immune system response is what make bird flu such a threat), to heart disease, to the aging process.

Ah yes, the aging process — that’s where my mother comes into the picture. I’m getting the feeling that many sorts of illness and breakdowns in old age are related to immune system failures, but are analyzed and treated on a more immediate, localized basis (e.g., heart condition, liver condition, lung condition, etc.). Since we are only starting to understand the immune system and what happens when age or environmental factors (toxins, pollution, smoking, viruses, etc.) mess it up, there are few or no practical therapies, never mind any cures. Most doctors probably don’t even want to talk about it (my mother’s doctors included). It’s frustrating to me, thinking that my mother has a condition that medicine is just not ready for yet.

SIDENOTE: Many of the classic autoimmune diseases are NOT old-age related; they manifest earlier in life, when the immune system is most potent. However, the control mechanisms for the immune system clearly deteriorate with age. So, if a person still has a strong immune response in their later years, as my mother does, the chance that their strength will turn against them increases.

I took a look on Google and the Amazon to see if there are any other autoimmune disciples out there. There does seem to be one; her name is Donna Jackson Nakazawa. She has a book out titled “The Autoimmune Epidemic: Bodies Gone Haywire in a World Out of Balance”. I’ve just ordered a copy of it; given my mother’s recent experience, I will give it priority over the many other interesting books stacked up in my apartment waiting to be read. The reviews and previews for Ms. Nakazawa’s book indicate that she focuses a lot on environmental factors, e.g. pollution and toxins in the air and water and our foods. She is mainly concerned about the possibility that a lot of people in their prime, and even children, are becoming weak and even sick before their time because of non-specific (and thus-far non-diagnosed) autoimmune processes triggered by these poisons.

My mother is now 86 and was fairly healthy most of her life. So, I can’t complain that the high levels of nasty stuff that we live with here in northern New Jersey prematurely robbed her of her vitality. But still, it’s a shame to think that perhaps she could have been up and kicking even longer if our industrial economy had done more to keep its noxious by-products from mucking up our planet (and if we knew how to eat the right things and avoid the wrong things so as to strengthen ourselves against it — which Ms. Nakazawa dwells on in her book).

And also if our medical establishment had not tried to jump over the immune system in its attempt to deal with cancer. Hopefully, the public and the political process will someday learn that medical researchers would do better right now by focusing on intermediate topics like the immune system; and thus stop throwing so much tax money at a problem that we just don’t have the tools yet to deal with (i.e., cancer). Let’s take a decade or two to develop those tools; that’s what make sense to me. But the researchers don’t want to say that out loud for fear of losing government and foundation grants. Oh well, such is the way of the world. I wish Ms. Nakazawa much success, but for now she seems to be a prophet crying out in the desert. Ah yes, back to the “40 days” theme!

◊   posted by Jim G @ 12:31 pm      
 
 


  1. Jim,
    So very glad to hear your mother is doing well (perhaps relatively well compared to her previous level of health) after her very severe crisis.

    As to the medical establishment and what it knows–and more importantly what it does not know: “We” generally have the impression that doctors know almost everything; even doctors themselves give the impression that they know everything when it comes to curing the human body.

    However, the more experienced ones generally realize that what they know about illness, how to cure the human body of it’s problems, what they can actually DO when it comes to so many medical problems is actually very limited.

    I am not saying that most likely the study of the immune system and how to help it help the body will prove to be the key in a great many diseases–those you mention, those that people have that are “mysterious” and are often attributed to some psychosomatic cause, and many others that are known about by the medical establishment but not included here.

    Yet, in the end we all finally have to realize that in the “foxhole” of having to deal with end-of-life-issues or issues that can cause end of life, there is so much that will turn out to be a mystery.
    MCS

    Comment by MCS — January 19, 2009 @ 7:40 am

  2. Jim,
    So very glad to hear your mother is doing well (perhaps relatively well compared to her previous level of health) after her very severe crisis.

    As to the medical establishment and what it knows–and more importantly what it does not know: “We” generally have the impression that doctors know almost everything; even doctors themselves give the impression that they know everything when it comes to curing the human body.

    However, the more experienced ones generally realize that what they know about illness, how to cure the human body of it’s problems, what they can actually DO when it comes to so many medical problems is actually very limited.

    I am not saying that most likely the study of the immune system and how to help it help the body will prove to be the key in a great many diseases–those you mention, those that people have that are “mysterious” and are often attributed to some psychosomatic cause, and many others that are known about by the medical establishment but not included here.

    Yet, in the end we all finally have to realize that in the “foxhole” of having to deal with end-of-life-issues or issues that can cause end of life, there is so much that will turn out to be a mystery.
    MCS

    Comment by MCS — January 19, 2009 @ 7:40 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment:


   

FOR MORE OF MY THOUGHTS, CHECK OUT THE SIDEBAR / ARCHIVES
To blog is human, to read someone's blog, divine
NEED TO WRITE ME? eternalstudent404 (thing above the 2) gmail (thing under the >) com

www.jimgworld.com - THE SIDEBAR - ABOUT ME - PHOTOS
 
OTHER THOUGHTFUL BLOGS:
 
Church of the Churchless
Clear Mountain Zendo, Montclair
Fr. James S. Behrens, Monastery Photoblog
Of Particular Significance, Dr. Strassler's Physics Blog
Weather Willy, NY Metro Area Weather Analysis
Spunkykitty's new Bunny Hopscotch; an indefatigable Aspie artist and now scholar!

Powered by WordPress